Thoughts to Action: Is It Free Will?

Arvind Mehrotra
3 min readDec 23, 2024

--

Today, we often take our thoughts and actions for granted, assuming they result from our free will. However, a closer look at the cognitive process reveals a complex interplay of factors that ultimately lead to our actions. This blog post will explore the different layers of thought and action, from the initial seed of an idea to the final execution of an action. We will also discuss the concept of mind control and its potential impact on our decision-making process.

I believe that there are Four Layers, from Thought to Action:

1. Seeded Thought: The journey begins with a thought seeded in our minds due to our active or alert cognition. External stimuli, such as a conversation, a news article, or a social media post, may trigger this thought. It may also be generated internally due to our reflections or daydreams. “The only way to dominate a person is to know him better than he knows himself.” — Aldous Huxley.

2. Initiating Thought: A question, observation, or experience can prompt the brain to process information. Feeling anxious might lead to thoughts about upcoming challenges. Initiation of an idea leads to the development of an initiating thought. Thus, the initiation of thought is due to the dynamic interplay of external inputs, internal states, and neural activity, with the influence of past experiences and ongoing interactions. The thought sets the mind in motion, prompting us to consider a particular action. “The mind is everything. What you think you become.” — Buddha.

3. Mind Control: At this stage, the mind may be subject to various influences, both internal and external. By tying obligations to values like loyalty, responsibility, or honour, individuals may feel compelled to conform, even against their personal preferences. Structured training programs often use repetition and reinforcement to instil specific behaviours and thought processes. These influences can shape our thoughts and perceptions, ultimately leading to a particular decision or action.

4. Final Step-Action: The final step is executing the action. It may involve physical activity, verbal communication, or other form of expression.

The concept of mind control raises important questions about the extent to which our thoughts and actions are indeed our own. Can external forces manipulate our minds? Can we be influenced to think or act in ways that are not in our best interests?

Thought leaders have criticised and supported the idea of mind control throughout history. Some argue it is a myth, while others believe it is a real and dangerous phenomenon. The criticism seems to be around the following:

· Free Will: Some argue that the idea of mind control undermines the concept of free will. They believe that humans are ultimately responsible for their thoughts and actions.

· Scientific Evidence: There is limited scientific evidence to support the existence of mind control. Most studies have focused on more subtle forms of influence, such as persuasion and suggestion.

· Oversimplification: The four-layer model of thought and action may oversimplify the complex cognitive processes that underlie human behaviour.

Looking at how we are influenced today by the idea “The mass mind is the most powerful force in history.” — Napoleon Bonaparte. Today, most actions seem to be about supporting:

· Subliminal Messages: Evidence shows that subliminal messages can influence people’s thoughts and behaviour.

· Social Influence: Social groups can influence individual behaviour, leading people to conform to group norms even when they conflict with their beliefs.

· Media Manipulation: The media can manipulate public opinion through selective reporting and framing of information.

The four layers of thought and action provide a framework for understanding the complex cognitive processes that lead to human behaviour. The concept of mind control raises important questions about the extent to which our thoughts and actions are indeed our own. While there is limited scientific evidence to support mind control, it is clear that various internal and external factors can influence our minds. It is essential to be aware of these influences and to make conscious choices about our thoughts and actions. Safeguards against mind control will enhance critical thinking, encourage scepticism and question-imposed obligations or teachings. Alternatively, exposure to diversity helps promote. Ultimately, it is about personal autonomy, strengthening an individual’s ability to make independent decisions.

--

--

Arvind Mehrotra
Arvind Mehrotra

Written by Arvind Mehrotra

Board Advisor, Strategy, Culture Alignment and Technology Advisor

Responses (1)